Why Are We Ignoring Right-Wing Threats to Our Security?
Sheila Musaji
Posted Aug 15, 2012 •Permalink • Printer-Friendly VersionWhy Are We Ignoring Right-Wing Threats to Our Security?
by Sheila Musaji
In an article on the Sikh Temple massacre, I commented on the many warnings we have had about the threat of homegrown right-wing terrorism that have been ignored:
Rep. Peter King held a series of “radicalization hearings which focused only on Muslim perpetrators. Our article Answers to Peter King’s Claims About the American Muslim Community discusses these hearings at length. When Rep. King was specifically asked to broaden the scope to include all radicalization no matter its source - he refused. In fact, his response was “To include other groups, such as neo-Nazis and extreme environmentalists in this hearing would be extraneous and diffuse its efficacy. It would also send the false message that our Committee believes that there is any threat equivalency between these disparate groups and Islamist terrorism. Very simply, the Committee cannot ignore the fact that al Qaeda is actively attempting to recruit individuals living within the Muslim American community to commit acts of terror…I will not allow political correctness to obscure a real and dangerous threat to the safety and security of the citizens of the United States.”
In 2009, Janet Napolitano warned about the threat from right-wing extremists, and she was ignored.
In 2010, FBI Director, Robert Mueller warned that homegrown extremists are as threatening as Al Qaeda. He was ignored.
In 2010, former President Bill Clinton issued a warning on the extremist mood in US. Clinton was quoted as saying in part “We are again dealing with difficulties in a contentious, partisan time … As we exercise the right to advocate our views, and as we animate our supporters, we must all assume responsibility for our words and actions before they enter a vast echo chamber and reach those both serious and delirious, connected and unhinged.” He was ignored.
In 2011, U.S. Rep. Michael McCaul, R-Texas, the chairman of the Homeland Security Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee introduced a bill to add 6 drug cartels to foreign terrorist list but it didn’t happen. He was ignored, even though U.S. authorities have reported a spike in killings, kidnappings and home invasions connected to Mexico’s cartels, and at least 19 Americans were killed in 2008. Another 92 Americans were killed between June 2009 and June 2010.
Our articles Claim that all terrorists are Muslims ignores history and 17,000+ “Islamic terrorist” attacks exist only in fevered Islamophobic brains provide a great deal of information on the fact that extremism, violence, and terrorism are not confined to Muslims. Also see Mother Jones’ A Guide to Mass Shootings in America which notes that “Since 1982, there have been at least 58 mass murders* carried out with firearms across the country, with the killings unfolding in 30 states from Massachusetts to Hawaii. We’ve mapped them below, including details on the shooters’ identities, the types of weapons they used, and the number of victims they injured and killed.”
Our regularly updated collection of violent or terrorist acts carried out by non-Muslims is very lengthy. We are only half way through 2012, and here are the updates that we have so far for this year. Each of these was referred to as an “isolated incident”:
UPDATES 2012
— January 2012, Samuel Arrington was arrested for a series of 55 arson fires across Los Angeles.
— Ray Lazier Lengend, a 40-year-old of Guyanese descent arrested on five counts of criminal possession of a weapon, five counts of arson one considered a hate crime for a series of molotov coctail firebombings in NYC (including a mosque).
— Anthony Graziano, a teenager was arrested following an investigation into the firebombing of a Rutherford synagogue, Congregation Beth El, and the home of Rabbi Nossom Schuman and his family earlier in the month.
— Dallin Morgan, and Joshua Hogan were arrested in Utah for allegedly planning to bomb their high school assembly and make their getaway in a stolen plane.
— Bobby Joe Rogers, 41, firebombed the American Family Planning Clinic in Pensacola, Florida with a Molotov cocktail; the fire gutted the building.
— March 2012: The Offices of Texas State Sen. Wendy Davis were firebombed
— April 2012: An abortion clinic in Grand Chute, Wisconsin was bombed.
— T.J. Lane, a student opened fire in a cafeteria at Chardon High School in Ohio, killing three students and injuring two others before he was arrested.
— J.T. Ready, a former Marine, a neo-Nazi and member of the anti-immigrant Minutemen Civil Defense Corps, strapped on body armor, grabbed several firearms, and then killed four people in Gilbert, Arizona. ** He was the target of an FBI terrorism investigation at the time of the shooting. **
— One Goh, a Korean American opened fire at a Christian college in California on Monday, killing at least seven people and wounding three
— Two men pleaded guilty to conspiring to buy weapons illegally for what federal agents describe as a terrorist plot by a fringe militia group. The F.B.I. recorded conversations in which the men, Frederick Thomas, 73, and Dan Roberts, 67, discussed plans to detonate explosives and shoot government workers in Atlanta, Georgia and other cities.
— Five people, claiming to be anarchists, have been arrested in Cleveland for trying to blow up a four-lane bridge across the Cuyahoga Valley National Park. Douglas Wright, 26, of Indianapolis; Brandon Baxter, 20, of Lakewood, Ohio; Anthony Hayne, 35, of Cleveland; Connor Stevens, 20, of Berea; and Joshua Stafford, 23, of Cleveland were arrested and charged with conspiracy and attempted use of explosive material to damage physical property affecting interstate commerce.
— Christopher Hecker was arrested and charged with making death threats against the president and threatened to bomb the White House, hotels and other places, including Philadelphia City Hall and the site of the former World Trade Center. **
— Twelve white supremacists have been arrested in Melbourne, Florida crime and criminal conspiracy charges filed stemming from an alleged plot to attack a rival, anti-racism group at a rally they expected to happen in downtown Melbourne. **
— Marcus Faella, Christopher Brooks, Richard Stockdale, Kent McLellan, Patricia Faella, Jennifer McGowan, Mark McGowan, Diane Stevens, Paul Jackson, and Dustin Perry, arrested in Florida. Members of a neo-Nazi organization known as the American Front 17 which is considered a domestic terrorism group. Arrested for “planning and preparing the AF for what he believes to be an inevitable race war” and had stated “his intent ... to kill Jews, immigrants and other minorities.” **
— Joseph Benjamin Thomas and Samuel James Johnson arrested for a plot to blow up the Mexican consulate in St. Paul, Minnesota, and attempting to form a militant supremacist group called the Aryan Liberation Movement targeting minorities, liberals, and government officials. **
— Samuel James Johnson was one of two people arrested that federal investigators say were white supremacists who had plans to attack. Specific details on the plot have not been released but what we do know is it included a number of guns and the intent to hurt government workers and minorities. The FBI says at some point, Johnson formed his own white supremacist group and was planning to recruit others in an attack against the government and minorities. He’s a former leader and member of the National Socialist Movement – a white supremacist group. **
— Darren Wesley Huff was convicted of transporting firearms across state lines with the intent to cause a civil disorder. Huff intended to arrest public officials pursuant to “citizens arrest warrants,” which were directed at numerous local, state, and federal public officials, including sheriffs, police chiefs, and President Obama. When arrested Huff carried in his vehicle a .45 caliber handgun and an AK-47 with ammunition. He told people that day that he had 300-400 rounds of ammunition with the AK-47 **
— Brian Church, Jared Chase, and, Brent Vincent Betterly, self-described anarchists, were arrested in Chicago in apparent plot to bomb Obama headquarters, and the mayor’s home ** Charged with conspiring to commit domestic terrorism **
— Unknown shooter killed one and injured seven in a Toronto Mall shooting. **
— James Holmes burst into the emergency exit door of a theater and shot 71 people, killing 12, at a midnight premiere of the new Batman movie **
— Wade Michael Page, a former Army Psyops specialist, and white-supremacist carried out terrorist attack on a Sikh Temple in Wisconsin, killing 6 and injuring 3 **
On TAM, we have published many articles discussing the dangers of terrorism, hate crimes, and violence from multiple sources. Those articles clearly show that both in the United States, and in Europe, most terrorist acts have been committed by non-Muslims.
There have been numerous serious reports and studies published that also make the point that Muslims are not only not the only source of threats to our homeland security, they are not even the main source of threats to our homeland security. For example: — Europol 2006 Report — Europol 2007 Report — U.S. Dept. of Justice ReportTerrorism 2002 to 2005 — 2009 Homeland Security Report which warned of rising right-wing extremism. — Duke University Report: Anti-Terror Lessons of Muslim-Americans — “MPAC REPORT: Data on Post-9/11 Terrorism in the United States,” SPLC report Terror From the Right. In fact, we have a collection listing numerous such studies Existing Reports, Polls, and Studies on Islam, Muslims & Radicalization.
This year, the FBI Issued a warning that anti-government extremists opposed to taxes and regulations pose a growing threat to local law enforcement officers in the United States. Reuters, the Washington Post and numerous others reported on this development. These Sovereign citizens reject the authority of the Federal government, and often refuse to obey laws or pay taxes. They deny that they are U.S. citizens and reject government authority to regulate their lives. They are often connected with militia groups like posse comitatus. The movement has been growing in prisons and spread by the internet. The Southern Poverty Law Center has written about a resurgence of this movement here which includes information about violent incidents, intimidation, harrasment of law enforcement officers and judges, threats, vandalism, stockpiling weapons, and murder. The ADL has an entry about the sovereign citizens movement under the category of extremism in America here. The ADL also has a list of sovereign citizens incidents by state here.
Here are the facts that we need to consider:
The Southern Poverty Law Center recently reported the highest number of hate groups ever recorded in U.S. history, with nearly 1,018 active groups.
Anti-Muslim hate groups have increased 300 percent in the last year, and the FBI reported a 50 percent increase in anti-Muslim hate crimes.
Think Progress reported that according to a DHS 2009 report (which was withdrawn due to backlash from from mainstream conservatives), since 1995, there has been only one year (2001) in which Islamic terrorism topped the domestic terror chart. During this time period, Islamic terrorism accounted for only 12% of the attacks on U.S. soil. Eco-terrorism accounted for 30%. Right wing extremists, have perpetrated fully 56% of domestic terror acts in the U.S. for the last 17 years.
The New America Foundation and Syracuse University’s Maxwell School have examined, charted, and analyzed 302 cases of homegrown jihadist and non-jihadist terrorism in the United States since the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. As Steve Coll noted about this report “Of the three hundred domestic-terrorism cases studied, about a quarter arose from anti-government extremists, white supremacists, or terrorists animated by bias against another religion. And all of the most frightening cases—involving chemical, biological, and radiological materials—arose from right-wing extremists or anarchists. None arose from Islamist militancy.”
For some reason, all of these facts have been ignored, and elected representatives and government officials have continued to falsely claim that somehow Muslims were the greatest threat to our national security. That is beginning to change, but it seems that the change is coming due to outside pressure. Just this week, two important articles were published by investigative journalists.
Jordan Michael Smith published an article on Salon FBI:// Right Wing Terror Is Real in which he reports some very interesting facts
... white supremacists and neo-Nazis have been recognized as genuine threats for years. FBI documents declassified in July reveal that the bureau has been worried about right-wing extremists for a long time — so many years, in fact, that many seem to have forgotten that white supremacists, who pioneered homegrown terrorism with the Ku Klux Klan, have not gone away.
The documents, which were collected by the invaluable National Security Archive and obtained partly through Freedom of Information Act requests, shed light on the problems coming from the extreme right. According to a 2004 FBI report, “right-wing terrorists pose a significant threat due to their propensity for violence” (note the FBI’s use of the term “right-wing” to define these terrorists, the phrase that so enraged conservatives when Napolitano employed it). These groups increased their recruitment efforts and rhetoric after 9/11, according to the report. White supremacists groups relied on broader anti-immigrant sentiment throughout the country to advance their efforts.